Ever since I bought my iPod, I’ve been a bit underwhelmed by the headphone market. It seems that the big names in audio aren’t developing new earbud/earphone products even though the popularity of mobile audio devices continues to rise.
First of all, the earphones that come with the iPod are a joke. They’re uncomfortable, fall out too easily, and sound like shit. I began looking for a replacement set the day my iPod arrived.
Because of their portability, I like canalphones, which are small headphones that fit inside the ear canal. I’m not really interested in any of the high end phones because I just can’t bring myself to spend over $150 dollars for headphones, although I understand that many people will and do every day.
So I fall into a large market segment of iPod users looking for a relatively inexpensive replacement set of earphones that meet some basic requirements.
- White, minimalistic look that compliments the iPod.
- Sound decent enough to make the listening experience enjoyable.
- Comfortable. Fit well in the ear and won’t fall out when running.
My first choice was the Apple In-Ear Headphones, but they’ve receieved some pretty lousy reviews on both their sound and fit. Browsing through sites like iLounge and headphone forums, I was surprised that a lot of the recommended products where not available in the US. Most people made their purchases from AudioCubes.com, a site based in Japan.
I ended up buying a pair of Sony MDR-EX51LP Headphones, which seemed to meet all of the requirements. The only thing that sucks about them, and pretty much all the other in-ear canalphones, is that instead of the standard “Y” split of the cords, the split is uneven. The left cord is short, only a few inches, while the right cord is much longer and is meant to wrap around the back of your neck.
To me it’s stupid and I hate the cords, but I kept the headphones anyway. After using these phones for over 6 months, I’ve never gotten used to it and have been waiting to try something else. Maybe these things are popular in Japan, but it seems most of the US consumers are like me and prefer the standard “Y” split.

Enter the Griffin EarThumps
A couple of weeks ago, Griffin Technology, creator of the popular EarJams, released the EarThumps. For only $20 bucks, they looked nice and more importantly had the standard “Y” split. There weren’t any reviews, but I went ahead a purchased them anyway.
I’ve had them for a few days now and I’m quite satisfied with them. They sound good enough overall with strong bass, look great, and are very comfortable. I’ve been running with them twice and for that they work well. And while they do not sound quite as good as the Sonys, I’ll forgo a little bit of sound quality for usability.
So why haven’t any of the big companies listened? It’s not like iPods and other mobile devices came out yesterday. Sure there are companies like Shure, Etymotic, & Sennheiser that focus on the high end niche, but not everyone wants to spend $300 on earphones. With active forums like the ones at iLounge and Head-Fi, it should be easy to get a grasp of what people want. Griffin listened and created a product that satisfies a large market segment’s needs. And until the rest catch up, they’ll reap the rewards.